A question I’ve been asked a lot by my students is this:
“What’s the difference between gain and volume? They seem like the same thing.”
And they’re right to ask that. They seem so similar! Does the difference even matter?
In a word: absolutely.
Knowing the difference between gain and volume could change the tone of your instruments forever.
Once you’ve finished reading, you’ll be making better mixes with more control over the tone of your instruments.
But first, make sure to grab our FREE volume balancing cheat sheet. Learning the difference between gain and volume is the first step. After that, you need to actually balance the volumes of your instruments together.
This guide will help you to make mixes that feel more powerful and consistent.
Grab it here:
What Is Volume?
Between the two, the definition of volume is pretty straightforward.
Volume usually means the decibel (dB) output of a sound system.
That sounds more complicated than it is. Basically, volume is how loud something is after it’s been processed.
So really, volume = loudness. It’s the loudness you hear.
If you’re mixing, the volume is whatever level is sent from your channel to your stereo output (or whatever bus you’re sending to).
If you’re using a guitar amp, the volume is how loud you set the amp.
If you’re in your car, the volume is how loud you turn your music up on your speakers.
Pretty simple, right?
Here’s the important thing: The volume does not change the tone of the sound. It just makes it louder.
So if That’s Volume, Then What’s Gain?
Gain is… more complicated.
In the analog days, gain was a very simple concept. But in the advent of the digital age, “gain” has started to mean several things.
This is because the makers of our digital tech have simultaneously tried to copy analog gear while also forging ahead to make their own stuff.
That’s led to some differences in definition:
Sometimes, gain is just another word for volume. So, the decibel (dB) output of a system.
You see this commonly on digital plugins. For instance, the “makeup gain” function on a compressor is really just the output volume with a different name.
However, the more popular definition for gain is the decibel (dB) input of a system.
So the gain controls how loud something is before it goes through any processing. It’s the volume level being sent into your plugins, preamps, and amplifiers.
This is an important distinction.
How loud something is AFTER processing doesn’t change the tone of the sound.
But how loud something is BEFORE processing definitely will.
Back in the analog days, gain was used in two ways:
There was the gain on the microphone preamp. This turned up the level of the mic, which would change how the analog tech in the recording console would affect it.
There was also the gain on a guitar amp, which turn up the level of the guitar. Most guitars had both a gain knob and a volume knob, meaning that you could send a ton of gain into the amp, overload it, then keep the volume reasonably quiet with the volume knob.
That’s how guitar distortion was created. Overloading the guitar amp with gain so that the speaker can’t process the guitar cleanly.
Because of this, gain sometimes has a third definition – distortion.
So in today’s world, gain means three things:
- Another word for volume, or how loud the output is
- How loud the input is
Be aware: when you’re mixing, you’ll probably see all three of these being used!
What About Gain Staging?
So now that you know what gain means, what’s gain staging all about?
Gain staging is a term that gets thrown around a lot. And that’s a good thing, because it’s so important!
Gain staging is the process of making the dB level of a sound consistent throughout the entire processing system.
So, basically, the level that’s coming into the channel is the same as the level coming out.
Gain staging is important because our ears perceive loud sounds as “better” than softer sounds.
So if we don’t make the loudness level consistent from one plugin to the next, then we won’t know if the plugin is actually making the instrument sound better or just louder. It makes our judgement way less accurate.
You need to do this with each plugin you use. For instance, if you put on a compressor, it’s important to use the makeup gain to “gain stage” (i.e. turn up the volume) to compensate for the volume lost.
If you put on an EQ, the same applies. Did you cut a bunch of frequencies? Then your overall level was probably turned down. You need to turn it back up with the volume knob.
Just put on a distortion? The instrument probably got a lot louder. Use your volume controls to turn the output of the distortion down to match the level of the input.
If you do this with each plugin, your mixes will improve dramatically, because you’ll be making more accurate mixing decisions.
It’s also important to gain stage each recording in your session. You want them all to be roughly the same level before you start mixing, particularly if they are all in the digital sweet spot. Click here to read an in-depth article on gain staging your recordings.
Bonus Tip: Mixing with Pink Noise
If you’re having trouble getting your volume balance right, try mixing with pink noise.
It gives you a solid reference level for how loud each part of your mix needs to be.
Conclusion: Gain Vs Volume
So remember: gain and volume are very similar concepts, but their difference is very important to your mix.
- Volume is how loud the OUTPUT of the channel or amp is. It controls loudness, not tone.
- Gain is how loud the INPUT of the channel or amp is. It controls tone, not loudness.
Hopefully this knowledge will help your mixes to be one step closer to radio ready.
Before you head out, make sure to grab our FREE volume balancing cheat sheet. Now that you understand the benefits of gain staging, this guide will help you take on the next step – and make mixes more powerful and consistent.
Download it here:
Songwriter and producer. Writer at Musician on a Mission. I’m here to help people make music that lasts.
17 comments on this article
I have been exploring for a little bit for any high-quality articles or blog posts in this kind of
area . Exploring in Yahoo I ultimately stumbled upon this web
site. Reading this information So i’m glad to show that I’ve a very
just right uncanny feeling I discovered just what I needed.
I so much undoubtedly will make sure to do not disregard
this site and give it a glance regularly.
Is distortion included in all subwoofers? I want to put one in my car for playing heavy metal songs. I’ll have to make sure that I get something that is compatible with my van.
Thanks for explaining the difference in such a detailed write-up.
helping one thanks for sharing
I believe you are incorrect in some of the things you state in “volume versus gain”
Guitars have never been fitted with a volume and a gain knob. An edit to change from “guitar” to “overdrive pedal” would be a fix as the OD pedal does allow heaps of gain aka distortion going into a guitar amplifier which in turn effects/affects the resulting tone coming out of the amp.
Highly comprehensive and elegant way to explain the difference between these things.
This article overall was helpful to me in understanding gain staging within a mix! However, I did want to clarify that if you set up a guitar amp in the way described with the gain (on an amp “Volume” as it turns out) cranked up and the volume (on an amp “Master Volume”) turned down, the distortion that results would not be a result of the speakers not being able to process the signal. Rather it would be the various components and tubes within the amplifier itself being pushed to the point of clipping. Speaker distortion (or “speaker breakup”) IS possible, but you’d have to also crank up the Master Volume to push those guys as well.
Gain does not control tone
Agreed. I think Roth is using “tone” in the very general sense often used by electric guitarists, where it incorporates not only EQ but also distortion (gain staging to drive a later stage hard, for example) and even time shift effects like chorus, flanging and so on.
Gain, in that sense, changes the “tone” by adding harmonics in later stages due to overdriving them into distortion. In my view, that’s very imprecise use of language for a general discussion about audio production.
I downloaded your free mixing course and it has improved my mixing skills tremendously! Thank you for providing a logical easy workflow for what could be extremely overwhelming. Excited to share what I’ve got!
Hi Dylan. I’ve really benefited from your articles on recording, gain staging in particular, but I’d like your clarification on gain staging. As background, I’m currently working on a CD project of my original tunes that have all been recorded. It is jazz, mainly piano, bass, drums and saxophone with some strings occasionally as background. I record on a Zoom R24 and then mix and master on Mixcraft 9 Pro. Everything was recorded at 16 bit (unfortunately not 24 bit per advice from someone) and most everything sounds good based on preliminary mixes of the 9 tracks. I plan to go back and re-do all of the mixing. I did not gain stage originally when I recorded (but followed the rules of thumb that came with the Zoom on setting levels) or when doing the original mixes but have adjusted the faders such that there is no clipping on the individual faders or the Master Bus. I do minimal effects processing to maintain the original sounds as much as possible (mainly eq cuts, some reverb, little if any compression, and some volume automation).
I’ve done some experimenting with gain-staging on some of the tracks using a Vozengo Span analyzer and a VU meter. Most of the tracks have an RMS of below -18 dbfs, often in the -20 to -24 range. Some are as low as -36. My question is: should I try to get every track sitting at around 0VU/-18rms by adjusting the gain? Or should I follow your advice and only adjust the gain on tracks peaking above -6 or below -30 dbfs and not mess with any tracks that don’t violate that standard but make sure the gain before and after plugins is the same. Or is there some minimal RMS or VU value I should shoot for in the case of tracks that are very low? I have tracks in the -26 to -20 range that are close to and sometimes peaking above -6. If I raise the gain on those It could put them well above -6 with occasional clipping. There’s lots of dynamic range on all of the instruments (except the bass) that I want to preserve to the extent possible. Any advice you have would be much appreciated.
If Gain controls Tone, is it the same as the Tone control? Then why do some mixers have both knobs?
Thanks for the article! Insightful and well written :)
Thank you very much for this clear and helpful explanation!
thanks for the input but why won’t you just normalize peaks to -0dB for all the stems and then set the volume of the stems to -18dB all at once?
checking my understading, Gain is actually the pre-effects volume…. Volume is after the effects.
if you don’t use any effects, the Gain isn’t relevant, right?
You’re right that “gain” is pre-processing level and “volume” is post-processing level! If you aren’t doing any processing at all (no EQ, no compression, no distortion, no delay, etc.), then gain isn’t relevant. If you are doing any level of processing in your mix, though, it definitely is.
Normalizing your tracks as a quick way to gain stage is possible, but risky. This may get a little complicated, so stick with me here… Most normalization is called “peak normalization,” meaning it sets the loudest peak to 0dB-FS. While that’s all well and good, we’re actually wanting the tracks to sit around -18dB-RMS (rather than -18dB-FS). RMS is the average level of the audio, whereas FS is the exact moment-to-moment level of the audio. So you’d want to use “RMS normalization” instead. However, if you try to normalize your tracks to 0dB-RMS, those tracks will distort, since many of the audio’s peaks will be above the 0dB threshold.
All this said, if you want to normalize your audio for quick gain staging, make sure to do RMS normalization, and make sure it’s set to WELL BELOW the 0dB mark, otherwise most of your tracks will distort. Many audio editors allow for -12dB normalization… that’s what I’d go for.
Also, if you’re doing the normalization technique of gain staging, you want to make sure you’re changing the *gain* of the tracks to -18dB-RMS, rather than the *volume*. Remember – if you’re wanting to do any processing, the gain needs to be set correctly. The volume can be set wherever you want it to be.
Hope that helped!
Having just blown the glass out of my windows by switching my amp to overdrive and cranking the gain up so far that my guitar was howling feedback, I wondered what exactly was the volume-gain relationship and how my knob twiddling affected the resultant output.
I must say your article was excellent, allowing me to consider my amp settings with a little more intelligence than previously, (and yes, I will be downloading the ‘cheat-sheet’ ;-)!).
Also, thankyou to ‘Reflected’ for the question above regarding normalisation/pre and post processing – the content of the question was enlightening in itself, and your detailed answer was much appreciated.
I’m gonna ‘bookmark’ this site so I can read the rest of the content, currently and in the future!!!
Now I’m off to read your pick of amp sims for 2019!
Keep up the good work!